BBC Apologises to Trump Over Misleading Speech Edit, Rejects Defamation Claim

The BBC has apologised to former US President Donald Trump for a misleading edit of one of his speeches. The broadcaster insists there is no basis for a defamation lawsuit. Chairman Samir Shah sent a personal letter to the White House expressing regret. The apology comes amid ongoing investigations into other possible edits.

The controversy began with a Panorama documentary aired in October 2024. It suggested Trump had directly urged “violent action” before the January 6, 2021, Capitol attack. The clip sparked backlash. The BBC director-general and the top news executive resigned. Trump’s lawyers threatened a $1 billion lawsuit.

In a statement, the BBC said Shah had written to Trump to convey that both he and the corporation were sorry. It added that while the edit was regrettable, it does not constitute defamation. BBC lawyers have told Trump’s team this formally.

The BBC is also probing a second possible misleading edit. A 2022 Newsnight report combined phrases from different parts of Trump’s speech. It made it appear as if he urged supporters to march on the Capitol and “fight like hell.” A BBC spokesperson said the matter is under review.

The controversy comes as the BBC prepares to renegotiate its Royal Charter, which expires in 2027. The issue puts the broadcaster in a sensitive position. It must balance editorial independence with political pressures. Prime Minister Keir Starmer and his government have backed the BBC’s autonomy while avoiding direct involvement.

As the investigation continues, the BBC faces scrutiny over its editorial practices. The case highlights the challenges of reporting on high-profile political figures. It also raises questions about credibility and accuracy in major news organisations.